DISTRICT COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
DIVISION OF ST. CROIX
5
SHERLINE WILLIAMS NATHANIEL, 5
5
Plaintiff,
5
2007-CV-0033
v.
5
5
AMERICAN AIRLINES, INC.,
5
5
Defendant. 5
____________________________________5
TO:
Lee J. Rohn, Esq.
Raegan M. King, Esq.
ORDER DENYING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL
THIS MATTER came before the Court upon Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel Defendant
to Supplement Rule 26 Disclosures (Docket No. 16).  Defendant filed an opposition to said
motion, and Plaintiff filed a reply thereto.
Having reviewed the filings of the parties and upon due consideration thereof, the
Court finds that Defendant has complied with its Rule 26 obligations and will deny the
motion to compel.
With regard to Plaintiff’s contention that she is entitled to the home addresses and
telephone numbers of certain employees of Defendant, the Court agrees with Defendant
Case: 1:07-cv-00033-RLF-GWC   Document #: 25   Filed: 04/16/08   Page 1 of 2
Nathaniel v. American Airlines, Inc.
2007-CV-0033
Order Denying Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel
Page 2
that such information of managerial or supervisory employees are not required to be
disclosed and that Defendant’s disclosures are adequate.
Plaintiff’s request for more details concerning the substance of the knowledge of
individuals with knowledge of the underlying incident who are not employees of
Defendant also extends beyond what is required by the rules.  As Defendant notes, its
description of the general scope of the individual’s knowledge is sufficient.
The Court accepts Defendant’s explanation for the redaction of the Flight History
and Event Detail Report.  The Court finds that further disclosure is not required.
Finally, Defendant asserts that it has not withheld any documents based upon any
claimed privileges at this juncture.  Consequently, Plaintiff’s demand for a privilege log is
premature.
Based upon the foregoing, it is now hereby ORDERED that Plaintiff’s Motion to
Compel Defendant to Supplement Rule 26 Disclosures (Docket No. 16) is DENIED.
ENTER:
Dated: April 16, 2008
                                /s/                                   
GEORGE W. CANNON, JR.
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE
Case: 1:07-cv-00033-RLF-GWC   Document #: 25   Filed: 04/16/08   Page 2 of 2